State of the Planet

News from the Columbia Climate School


Sailing Stone Track Discovered ‘Hiding in Plain Sight’ in Dinosaur Fossil

dinosaur footprints and sailing stone track
This slab of sandstone has been on display since 1896, showing off the scaly footprints of a prosauropod dinosaur. Scientists only recently realized that the deep grooves on the left may be the track of a sailing stone. Credit: Lull, R.S., 1915

A sandstone slab prized for its detailed dinosaur footprints may also contain the track of a sailing stone or “walking rock.” Paleontologist Paul Olsen from Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory announced this discovery in a presentation at the meeting of the American Geophysical Union on Monday. He and his colleagues think the trail of the walking rock is evidence of a brief freezing event in the tropics some 200 million years ago — the first evidence that volcanic winters reached into the humid tropics during the dawn of the dinosaur age.

The slab has been on display since 1896 — most recently at Dinosaur State Park in Connecticut, the state where it was originally discovered. It shows off the scaly footprints of a Brontosaurus predecessor that lived in the tropics during the Early Jurassic period. But nobody noticed the sailing stone track until Olsen and his colleagues came along in 2017.

Sailing stones are rocks and boulders move across flat landscapes without the help of gravity, people, or animals, carving tracks as they go. How do they move? Scientists know of two ways: by sliding on thick, slimy microbial mats, and when they’re pushed by thin ice sheets that form temporarily over shallow lakes.

sailing stones in desert
Sailing stones in Death Valley. The parallel tracks suggest these were moved by a thin ice sheet. Credit: Daniel Mayer, Wikimedia Commons

The researchers can’t say for sure whether it was one sailing stone or several that scraped this particular surface, but whatever it was, it was heavy enough to dig significant grooves in the ancient mud. A heavy object requires a thick microbial mat to lubricate its movement, but if such a thick mat was present, it would have prevented the detailed dinosaur footprints from forming.

“When the microbial mat gets thick, it actually shields the mud from the details of the foot,” explains Olsen. Furthermore, he adds, the surface doesn’t bear any of the usual markings of a thick microbial mat.

That left the other explanation: that the object was pushed by ice. That was surprising, because the track was laid down back when Connecticut was located at around the same latitude as the modern-day Yucatan peninsula. The site was at a relatively low elevation that would have experienced a tropical climate, and through most of the beginning of the Age of Dinosaurs, many of the animals and plants in the region were frost-intolerant. “There are no reasons to think that freezing would be a normal situation there,” says Olsen.

However, he and his colleagues have a potential explanation. The sandstone was deposited during the last of a series of eruptions that caused a mass extinction. The eruptions also blasted huge amounts of sulfur aerosols into the atmosphere that likely produced brief periods of global cooling, by shielding the Earth from receiving a normal amount of sunlight. However, paleoclimatologists don’t know how much sulfur was dumped into the atmosphere or how much cooling occurred. The new finding suggests that the planet may have cooled to such an extent that even the tropics froze.

“This may be evidence of the cooling caused by the volcanic winter,” says Olsen.

If the massive cooling event did reach the tropics, it is possible that the dinosaurs’ feathers provided insulation that helped them to survive the cold.

At the global scale, the freezing conditions during this time wiped out large non-insulated reptiles on land, opening up ecological space for insulated dinosaurs to dominant the planet.

Olsen cautions that the volcanic winter interpretation is “is not iron-clad,” because the team can’t entirely rule out the possibility that microbial mats allowed the rocks to sail.

Fortunately, there is a way to solve the mystery: If there were thin ice sheets in this region, then they likely moved other rocks as well. “If you could find them moving in synchrony, that would really indicate that it was ice, without a question,” says Olsen.

drawing of dinosaur and proto-mammal
If a volcanic winter did occur in the tropics 200 million years ago, feathers and fur may have helped these two to survive the cold. Credit: Paul Olsen

The team also discovered the footprints of a primitive mammal in the same sandstone slab, which had similarly gone unnoticed for more than 100 years. The mammal, sailing stone, and dinosaur likely passed by the same spot within a few days or weeks of each other.

The group will be submitting the findings to be published in a peer-reviewed journal. Co-authors include: James A Hyatt from Eastern Connecticut State University; Patrick Getty from Collin College, TX; Nicholas G. McDonald, affiliated with the Yale Peabody Museum, CT; Peter M LeTourneau and Clara Change from Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory; Morgan F Schaller from Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, NY; and Michael Ross, director of Dinosaur State Park, CT.

Banner featuring a collage of extreme heat images.

Recent record-breaking heat waves have affected communities across the world. The Extreme Heat Workshop will bring together researchers and practitioners to advance the state of knowledge, identify community needs, and develop a framework for evaluating risks with a focus on climate justice. Register by June 15

Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Kirk Geno
Kirk Geno
4 years ago

i assume that this slab is a sandstone. The footprints appear to be a cast which means the mold (depression of actual footprints) was in the underlying layer.

The track of the sailing stone, however, appears to be be a depression in the sandstone layer meaning that in the underlying layer it was a ridge. How can the subject feature be a sail stone track when It was was a ridge, not a furrow, as would have been left by a sail stone?

Jack means
Jack means
4 years ago

Very interesting, sailing stone theory, quite a reach?

Kerry Mills
Kerry Mills
4 years ago

I’m just a lay person but a more likely scenario is this is the track left by a tail dragger. I’ve seen the sailing stones in Death Valley too and found them incredible. Also have seen foot prints in mud… Those prints often give other clues about the artist. Odd the graphic shows extremely long-tailed creatures holding their tails up…. Look at existing reptiles. Not hard imagine footprints of the one who left this track are out of frame of the stone.