Highlights
- An analysis of Hawaiian volcanic rocks suggests carbon from Earth’s core can travel through the mantle and reach the surface in volcanic eruptions.
- Carbon found in Kīlauea samples had an unusual isotopic signature resembling that of ancient, carbon-rich meteorites.
- The findings support the theory that meteorites delivered much of Earth’s carbon late in the planet’s formation—including carbon that eventually became essential to life.
Carbon is a building block of all life on Earth. But where did the planet’s carbon come from?
A pioneering analysis of volcanic rocks suggests much of it came from meteorites that struck Earth during a specific time in Earth’s formation. The rocks contain traces of carbon dioxide with an isotopic signature researchers say likely originated from the planet’s core.
“We think that we found evidence of carbon from Earth’s core leaking into the core-mantle boundaries and traveling all the way to the surface,” says the study’s lead author, Yves Moussallam, an associate professor in Columbia’s Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences, Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory. The study appears in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
Immediately below Earth’s crust is its mantle, which is made of solid rock and stretches down about 1,800 miles. Beneath the mantle is Earth’s outer core, a layer of molten liquid some 1,400 miles thick that surrounds the dense, ultra-hot ball of metal that is the inner core.
Most of Earth’s carbon is thought to be contained in the core, which has never been directly sampled and probably never will be. However, recent research suggests that elements from the outer core can enter the mantle and eventually be carried to the planet’s surface by mantle plumes: buoyant columns of rock that form where the core meets the mantle, rise, melt as they approach the crust, and then feed volcanic eruptions as magma.
As the magma cools and solidifies, crystals form inside it. Sometimes the crystals encase droplets of magma and seal them so completely that gases dissolved in the magma do not escape. The resulting structures are called undegassed melt inclusions. They give scientists an indirect way to investigate the carbon that may have come from Earth’s core. “These melts are fossils of the magma,” Moussallam says.
Among the gases dissolved in magma is carbon dioxide. Earlier research identified Hawaii’s volcanoes as rich sources of mantle plume-derived magma, making them an ideal place to search for carbon that might have come from Earth’s core.

Using a recently developed method for measuring carbon isotopes, inside undegassed melt inclusions, Moussallam’s team analyzed inclusions in rocks formed by lava from eruptions at Kīlauea and the Tantalus Rift.
Eruptions from the Tantalus Rift are thought to contain magma that comes from the outer edges of mantle plumes, and earlier research suggested that mantle carbon typically has a carbon-isotope signature of around -5 to -7 per mil, which is close to what Moussallam’s team found in the Tantalus Rift samples.
Magma that flows beneath Kīlauea is believed to come from the center of the mantle plume, which is thought to originate near the core-mantle boundary. The carbon in the Kīlauea samples was distinctly heavier, with a signature of about -1 per mil. That signature has only rarely been documented before.
“This signature is very, very distinct from the normal mantle” says Moussallam. “This means it must have been contaminated by another carbon source and that source is probably carbon from the core.” That core origin isn’t a certainty, Moussallam says, and further research is needed to confirm it. But he and his colleagues think it’s the most likely explanation.
Moussallam says that carbon isotopic signatures of Earth’s core should reflect “the signature of the building blocks of Earth when it was created.” When they compared the Kīlauea carbon signatures to those found in meteorites, they found similarities to a type known as carbonaceous chondrites.
Chondrites are more than 4.5 billion years old and considered among the oldest matter in our solar system. “All of Earth is made of chondrites,” Moussallam explains. “They’re the building blocks of all the terrestrial planets.” There are two types: so-called noncarbonaceous chondrites, which formed in the inner solar system, and carbon-rich carbonaceous chondrites that formed in the solar system’s periphery.
Scientists have disagreed about the roles each type played in Earth’s history. Moussallam and colleagues say their findings suggest that carbonaceous chondrites likely played a crucial part, pelting Earth late in its formation, when the growing planet was better able to retain carbon from incoming material, and delivering the carbon that would one day become fundamental to life.
That, at least, is their theory. “We don’t really know. We need more measurements,” cautions Moussallam.
Even so, says Moussallam, “It’s fun to think about. We’re made of carbon, right? To think that some of this carbon might at some point have been linked to iron in the planet’s core, made it all the way to the surface from out of a volcano, and is now part of the biosphere, is very interesting.”
The study was coauthored by Guillaume Georgeais, HyunJoo Lee and Bridgett Holman at Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory; Damanveer S. Grewal at Yale University; Estelle F. Rose-Koga at Institut des Sciences de la Terre d‘Orléans; Allan Lerner at the US Geological Survey; Paul J. Wallace at the University of Oregon; Natália Gauer Pasqualon at the University of Hawai’i; Olivia E. Anderson at Brown University; and Matthew G. Jackson at UC Santa Barbara.



