State of the Planet

News from the Columbia Climate School

Two Wren Brains Are Better Than One

When we participate in a balloon toss, dance the tango, or sing a duet, we experience a delightful feeling of unity, a seamless and powerful collective identity. The shared mental space is essential to the success of cooperative behaviors, guiding team members to make decisions and communicate messages that accomplish an objective.

The Gibbon wolf pack pauses in the snowy landscape – Photo by Doug Smith

Foraging, mating, reproduction, hunting, parental care, and countless other behaviors are simply less effective when done alone; evolutionarily, the social animal is often the more successful one. Among vertebrates, the brain reflects the advantages and power of two, as demonstrated by behavioral neuroscientist Eric Fortune in the November 4 issue of the journal Science.

As reported by Science Daily, Fortune, of the Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences at the Krieger School of Arts and Sciences, traveled to the cloud forests of Ecuador near Antisana Volcano to study plain-tailed wrens. These so-called bamboo specialists birds are famous for their unusually repetitive and rolling duets. The two-part choruses take an ABCD form, where the male sings the A and C phrases and the female sings the B and D phrases. Fortune and his team tape-recorded the birds’ singing and made detailed measurements of the timing and sequences of the syllables to evaluate the performance.

Plain-tailed wren, Bellavista, Pichincha, Ecuador – Photo by Browerk

When the researchers observed activity in the brains of the birds while singing, they discovered something striking: In both sexes, the neurons reacted more strongly to the duet song than individual contributions — they are seemingly wired to enhance cooperation.

As explained by Fortune, the kind of phenomena observed in the plain-tailed wrens is ubiquitous among vertebrates. The brains of frogs, dogs, sharks, monkeys, and even humans are very similar on the molecular level. For many species, emotions like shame, love, guilt, and honor drive cooperative behaviors, uniting a group of individuals to increase their chances of surviving and reproducing.

While debate surrounds the exact mechanism of selection for cooperative behaviors (with David Sloan Wilson and Group Selection in one corner and Richard Dawkins and Gene Selection Theory in the other), the importance of working together is evident, both in our daily lives and in the inner-workings of the vertebrate brain.

CERC provides a course on concepts of biological evolution, from pre-Darwinian attempts to describe life through modern genetic theory. It emphasizes the history of evolutionary thought and science, reviews the basic principles of evolutionary theory, and discusses their implications for modern life as well as state-of-the art technologies, such as genomics. Topics covered include natural selection, types of fitness and variation, speciation, reproduction and the transfer of genetic traits, the structure of DNA and a look at evolution over the long term via introductory systematics.

This course is part of CERC’s Certificate Program in Conservation and Environmental Sustainability. Courses may be taken on an individual basis or you may pursue the full 12-course Certificate. Interested in learning more? Visit our website or contact CERC for more information: or 212-854-0149.

Banner featuring a collage of extreme heat images.

Recent record-breaking heat waves have affected communities across the world. The Extreme Heat Workshop will bring together researchers and practitioners to advance the state of knowledge, identify community needs, and develop a framework for evaluating risks with a focus on climate justice. Register by June 15

Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments